Prior to 1867, the Chinese communities in the Straits Settlements of Penang, Malacca, and Singapore were administered through the Kapitan system, where an influential individual was appointed by the colonial government to represent their ethnic community. Following the establishment of the Straits Settlements Legislative Council in 1867, the colonial government's administration of Chinese communities shifted away from Kapitan to 'unofficial' members of the Legislative Council (as opposed to members who were government officials). 'Unofficial' legislative councillors linked the Chinese communities of the Straits Settlements with the colonial administration as the Kapitan once did,. albeit in a diminished role. This article traces the evolution of ethnic administration in the Straits Settlements and the role of the Kapitan and 'unofficials' in the expansion of British authority over Asian subjects. It argues that the replacement of the Kapitan by the unofficial was part of a broader shift from indirect to direct rule, and illustrates the role played by individuals in these positions in challenging British authority.